The Ti West-directed Christmas Carol retelling grossed roughly $42-43 million worldwide, enough for the top spot but short of the comeback numbers Depp needed.
Ebenezer won the weekend. Nobody's arguing with that. What's up for debate is whether Johnny Depp's first mainstream lead role since 2018 counts as a real comeback or just a solid, unspectacular Tuesday for Paramount's accountants.
Collider put the domestic number at $20 million. IndieWire had it at $19 million. Both agree the global total landed somewhere around $42 to 43 million, split roughly $19-20 million at home and $23 million overseas. For a movie that reportedly cost under $40 million to make, that's a number studios can live with, even if it's not the kind that gets a victory lap.
The film is Ti West's go at A Christmas Carol, with Depp playing Ebenezer Scrooge opposite a cast that includes Daisy Ridley, Sam Claflin, Rupert Grint, Andrea Riseborough, Tramell Tillman and Ian McKellen. It opened a reported $10 million behind Jim Carrey's 2009 big-budget version but ahead of The King of Kings, the other Dickens-adjacent release still circling theaters this month.
Audiences liked it more than critics did. Ebenezer carries an A- CinemaScore and a 90% "Verified Hot" audience score on Rotten Tomatoes, against a critics' score sitting at 54%. The site's consensus called the production design evocative but said the film "plays things too safe to stand out amongst its long line of remakes."
What the opening weekend tells you about Depp
IndieWire's read is the sharper one: Depp is a draw again, but only at the right price. He reportedly took a $5 million paycheck here, a steep cut from his old Pirates of the Caribbean rate, and Paramount kept him away from interviews likely to press on the Amber Heard trial or the years he spent fired off franchises and shuffled into straight-to-streaming work.
The audience breakdown backs that caution up. Per IndieWire, 59% of domestic ticket buyers were over 30, slightly more women than men bought tickets, and families made up just 9% of the opening crowd for a PG-13 holiday title, usually the demographic that drives this kind of release through December.
Still, the arithmetic works in Paramount's favor. A $38 million budget means Ebenezer only needs legs through the holiday season and continued overseas play to turn a profit, and distributors will take that trade every time over a flashier opening that can't cover its costs.
Depp's bigger test comes in March, when Lionsgate releases Day Drinker, the action thriller that's being pitched as his real return to leading-man status. There's also fresh chatter about Depp returning to Pirates of the Caribbean, though nothing beyond talks has been confirmed. Whether Ebenezer reads as the first step back or as proof that his audience has simply gotten smaller depends on how both of those play out.
Be the first to comment
Join the argument. No password, just your email or a passkey.