Skip to content
Jessica Chastain in a tense scene from the horror film 'Other Mommy', looking frightened in dim lightingPhoto via The Hollywood Reporter

Other Mommy Gets Roasted in Early Reactions

Jessica Chastain's latest horror film is drawing sharp criticism despite strong box office expectations and a viral teaser.

By Overseas1 min read

In this story

Current hype level85

Live site hype

around 2 reading right now · 295 today

The horror film Other Mommy has landed with a thud in early screenings, sparking backlash from critics who found the movie more absurd than terrifying. Despite a chilling teaser that sent audiences into fits of dread, the Blumhouse/Atomic Monster production is now being described as one of the year’s most disappointing entries in the genre.

Jessica Chastain plays a mother haunted by a demonic presence affecting her daughter, a premise drawn from Josh Malerman’s novel Incidents Around the House. Directed by Rob Savage — known for Host, the film promised a relentless barrage of fear, with Savage himself claiming around 50 jump scares across its runtime. That averages to one every two minutes, but many viewers say the effect was anything but effective.

The Jam Report called it an "excruciating parade of ineffective jump scares," while Screen Space labeled it a "ponderously paced" disaster that tries too hard to be elevated horror but lands in confusion. Global Box Office went further, branding it Chastain’s worst film in years, citing sloppy direction and a forgettable score. Even some fans of the genre admitted to laughter during the screening, not from amusement, but disbelief.

Yet not all voices are negative. Goldwin Reviews gave it a 4/5, praising its layered ambition and willingness to reinvent itself. The AU Review acknowledged technical skill in manipulating space and perspective but lamented the lack of depth in Chastain’s character beyond surface-level menace.

Universal had opted against traditional critic screenings, likely to avoid early damage ahead of Friday’s wide release. But word is spreading fast. Sean Kelly on Movies noted he only got in through a last-minute +1, underscoring how tight access was. Still, the film is expected to open to $20 million, buoyed by strong advance sales and the star power of Chastain.

Now the real test begins: will audiences care about the script or just the scares? Or will the laughs keep coming long after the credits roll?

Reported from

This article was written by the CutMirchi desk from the reporting above. Facts are attributed to their original publishers.

What did you make of it?

Be the first to comment

Join the argument. No password, just your email or a passkey.

    Read next