Rajkumar Hirani and Abhijat Joshi have spoken out about the long-standing controversy around Aamir Khan’s Lord Shiva scene in PK, saying it was never meant to mock faith — just to question belief with childlike innocence.
The scene still stirs debate — nearly a decade after PK’s release. Aamir Khan, as an alien named PK, mistakes a stage performer dressed as Lord Shiva for the real deity. The moment, where he chases the actor through a crowd, sparked outrage among some viewers who saw it as sacrilegious.
Now, in a rare public reflection, Rajkumar Hirani and Abhijat Joshi are defending their intent. They say they never set out to offend. Not even once. 'We didn’t at all' fear backlash, Hirani said.
Joshi added, 'The person in question is not Lord Shiva at all. He’s an actor performing a role.' The distinction matters. It wasn’t a depiction of the god. It was a performance, one that PK, unfamiliar with Hindu iconography, interprets literally.
That’s the point. As Hirani explained, 'PK happens to assume that he’s God. There was no intention to make fun.' The film’s entire premise hinges on seeing religion through the eyes of someone who doesn’t understand it, not to ridicule, but to reflect. 'It’s coming from a place of humility,' Joshi said.
'We duly respect people’s sentiments.' And yet, the backlash came anyway. 'Phir gussa aata hai ki jo baat hai hi nahin, usko issue banaya gaya,' he admitted, a line that’s already gone viral in response. The filmmakers aren’t apologising. But they’re clear: this wasn’t satire.
It was inquiry. Innocence, not irony, was the lens. Still, the conversation lingers. Was it too risky?
Too blunt? Or was it simply misunderstood? No verdict. Just a reminder: sometimes, the most controversial moments come from the quietest intentions.
And the next time you watch PK, ask yourself, what were we really questioning?
Be the first to comment
Join the argument. No password, just your email or a passkey.