Trade observers say the Telugu star's menacing avatar in Ranabaali feels forced rather than ferocious, reviving old questions about his run of mass-hero casting since Arjun Reddy.
Ranabaali was billed as one of the bigger Telugu releases of the year and, more pointedly, as the film that would pull Vijay Deverakonda out of a rough patch. Going by the reaction trade outlet Mirchi9 has put out, that reset hasn't happened.
The film arrived with promotional material that was already seen as underwhelming, and expectations rode entirely on Vijay delivering something that would quiet the critics. Mirchi9's assessment is blunt: the character gives him little beyond looking intense and threatening, and what starts off as menacing slides into something closer to caricature a few scenes in. The report notes mannerisms that don't sit naturally on him, calling the whole thing a miscasting problem rather than an effort problem. Vijay, per the piece, is clearly trying. It just isn't landing.
A pattern bigger than one film
The comparison being drawn is to Nani in The Paradise, where a similar over-the-top, aggressive template reportedly didn't work either. Mirchi9 points out that Nani only leaned into this harder mass-hero mode from around Dasara onwards, after years of feel-good films that connected with audiences. Vijay's arc is read as longer and more entrenched, stuck in a mass-hero lane going back to Arjun Reddy, with his detours into other genres not producing anything that's stuck in people's memory either.
The larger question the report raises is about process, not just performance: are actors like Vijay and Nani committing to scripts that are actually finished, or walking onto sets while things are still being figured out, with reshoots and mid-production rewrites papering over the cracks. That's a charge about the Telugu mass-hero assembly line as much as about any one actor.
There's also a commercial logic being spelled out here. Mass action remains the quickest route to pan-India ambitions, which is presumably part of why Vijay keeps returning to it. But the report argues that going mass doesn't have to mean playing an invincible alpha in every single scene, and suggests romance-action as a middle path, one that lets a star's screen presence sit alongside some emotional texture instead of wall-to-wall intensity.
Online, the Ranabaali conversation has splintered in the usual ways, with Vijay's fanbase pushing back against what they see as unfair pile-on and comparisons to Rajinikanth doing the rounds, mostly as a stick to beat the film with rather than a serious critique. Mirchi9's piece pushes back on that defensiveness directly, arguing that repeated box-office stumbles earn honest scrutiny and that no amount of promotional push changes what's on screen.
What happens next for Vijay Deverakonda isn't clear yet. No new project or script has been mentioned in connection with a course correction. But the pressure to pick something that isn't just another variation on the snarling alpha hero is only going to get louder from here.
Be the first to comment
Join the argument. No password, just your email or a passkey.