Aaron Sorkin says he spent a three-day weekend building a persuasion case for Jesse Eisenberg before casting Jeremy Strong in The Social Reckoning, which opens October 9.
Aaron Sorkin had the script nearly finished and no doubts that Jesse Eisenberg would come back. He was wrong, and by his own account, badly wrong.
Speaking to Entertainment Weekly, the writer-director said it genuinely did not occur to him that Eisenberg would turn down a return as Mark Zuckerberg for The Social Reckoning, his sequel to The Social Network. Sorkin recalled running into Eisenberg when he was "just a couple of pages from being done" with the draft, telling him something was coming his way. Eisenberg, he says, smiled and nodded.
Then came the no.
What followed, by Sorkin's telling, was unusual even for him. He wrote himself an actual outline, the kind he says he never bothers with for his films, purely to structure his pitch to Eisenberg across a three-day weekend. The arguments included that Eisenberg had already proven he could nail the role once, and that the sequel had strong moments written in for him. None of it moved the needle.
Sorkin's read on the refusal, relayed to EW, is that it was never about the paycheck. "Money does not motivate Jesse," he said, calling it "infuriating" in the moment but also "admirable," tying it to Eisenberg's reluctance to raise his kids around too much wealth. The bigger issue, per Sorkin, is that Eisenberg is tired of being physically and professionally tied to Zuckerberg, a role that's arguably defined his career since 2010.
The studio made an offer. Eisenberg didn't want the money attached to it either, according to Sorkin, which he frames as a disincentive rather than a draw.
Jeremy Strong landed the part last September, and The Social Reckoning hits theaters October 9. The sequel shifts focus from Facebook's founding to the 2021 leak that blew open the company's internal knowledge of the harm its platform caused. Mikey Madison plays whistleblower Frances Haugen, with Jeremy Allen White as Wall Street Journal reporter Jeff Horwitz, the journalist she approached with the documents. Bill Burr, Wunmi Mosaku, Billy Magnussen and Betty Gilpin round out the cast.
What's notable is how little daylight there seems to be between Sorkin's account and reality as he understands it. He's not spinning the rejection as mutual or amicable in some vague studio-speak way. He's saying he made a real case, on paper, and lost anyway.
Whether Strong's Zuckerberg invites comparison to Eisenberg's Oscar-nominated original or stands on its own is the question the film now has to answer on its own terms. Sorkin's outline didn't work on its intended audience of one. Audiences get the next say starting October 9.
Be the first to comment
Join the argument. No password, just your email or a passkey.